Failure to Provide Proper CPR and Airway Management for Tracheostomy Patient with Passy-Muir Valve
Summary
The deficiency involves the facility’s failure to provide appropriate basic life support, including CPR and airway management, to a tracheostomy-dependent resident who was a full code. The resident had multiple respiratory-related diagnoses, including respiratory failure with hypoxia, tracheostomy status, COPD, tracheomalacia, stridor, and a history of recurrent airway concerns. She used a Passy-Muir one-way speaking valve and had physician orders for full code status, routine tracheostomy care with suctioning every shift and as needed, and scheduled nebulized bronchodilator treatments. The manufacturer’s instructions for the Passy-Muir Valve specified that the valve should be removed if the patient exhibited signs of respiratory distress and that it was contraindicated when the patient was unconscious. The facility’s tracheostomy/CPR policy required staff to assess consciousness, call 911, check breathing and pulse, assess the tracheostomy for plugging or dislodgement, suction as needed, and provide rescue breaths via a resuscitation bag to the tracheostomy. On the night of the event, the assigned nurse documented that around midnight she performed tracheostomy care, removed the Passy-Muir Valve, and did not need to suction at that time. Later, around 5:00–5:15 a.m., she again provided medications, tracheostomy care, a nebulizer treatment, and light suctioning of a small amount of clear secretions, then replaced the Passy-Muir Valve. Vital signs at that time included a respiratory rate of 18 and oxygen saturation of 96% on 2 L via trach collar, and the resident was described as alert, oriented, and talkative with no complaints. Around 6:00–6:15 a.m., two nurse aides entered the resident’s room to provide incontinence care and found her unresponsive and not breathing; one aide reported finding no pulse, while the nurse later stated she initially found the resident warm with a faint pulse. The aides left the resident and went to the nurses’ station to notify the nurse, and the nurse went to the room, briefly assessed the resident, then returned to the nurses’ station to verify code status and figure out how to call a Code Blue overhead. After the Code Blue was called, staff brought the emergency cart and backboard to the room and initiated CPR. Multiple staff interviews consistently indicated that chest compressions were started and that a nurse aide was instructed by the nurse to use the resuscitation bag over the resident’s mouth and nose, not over the tracheostomy. Staff also reported that the nurse did not assess the tracheostomy, did not remove the Passy-Muir Valve, and did not suction the tracheostomy during the code, despite the resident having a tracheostomy and a Passy-Muir Valve in place. The nurse later confirmed she did not check the tracheostomy airway or remove the Passy-Muir Valve at any point and clarified that the resuscitation bag was kept over the resident’s mouth for all respirations. When EMS arrived, they found staff performing CPR with an AED attached and a resuscitation bag being used over the mouth without oxygen. EMS removed the Passy-Muir Valve, noted it was filled with secretions and buildup, and found the tracheostomy tube plugged, requiring multiple rounds of deep suctioning before effective ventilation through the tracheostomy could be achieved. The Medical Director and the Passy-Muir company’s clinical representative both stated that respirations during CPR for a tracheostomy patient must be provided at the tracheostomy site and that the Passy-Muir Valve should be removed when the patient is in respiratory distress or unconscious. The resident was transported to the hospital, where records documented a large mucus plug in the tracheostomy and listed acute on chronic respiratory failure with anoxic brain injury, mucus plug, and tracheal stenosis status post tracheostomy as causes on the death certificate.
Penalty
Resources
Below are regulatory guidelines relevant to this citation:
The facility failed to maintain documentation that 14 of 41 licensed nurses had current CPR certification for Healthcare Providers. CPR cards were not available for several RNs and LPNs, and the NHA and DON confirmed the facility did not ensure these nurses maintained current CPR certification in accordance with accepted national standards.
An agency CNA found a full code resident unresponsive, but an agency RN did not check for a pulse or vital signs and did not start CPR before leaving to call EMS and look for help. Staff present were not CPR certified, and EMS arrived to find the resident pulseless and apneic with no CPR started by the facility. The resident later died at the hospital.
Facility staff failed to ensure that an LPN and a CNA maintained current CPR certification while working scheduled shifts. Interviews with the Administrator, DON, and HR Director confirmed that RNs, LPNs, and CNAs were expected to hold active CPR cards, and record review showed the LPN’s CPR had expired before renewal while the CNA could not produce a valid CPR card for the employee file. Staffing schedules showed both employees worked multiple shifts despite the lapse, and the job descriptions for both roles required current CPR certification.
A full-code resident with atrial fibrillation, liver cirrhosis, and osteomyelitis was found unresponsive after a family member alerted staff to breathing trouble. Staff entered the room without emergency equipment, and CPR was not started promptly; records and interviews showed delays in recognizing the emergency, calling Code Blue/911, and bringing in the AED, AMBU bag, and crash cart. The resident later expired, and the death certificate listed myocardial infarction as the cause of death.
LPNs and RNs did not maintain current CPR certification for Healthcare Providers with a required hands-on component. Facility policy required active CPR certification for licensed nurses, but review of certification cards showed that 16 of 33 licensed nurses had only online-only CPR training for non-healthcare providers. The HR Director, NHA, and DON confirmed the deficiency.
A resident with CHF was found unresponsive and CPR was performed even though the chart contained an active DNR order, an MDS indicating DNR, and a POLST choosing DNR and allowing natural death. LN stated she reviewed the physician order at the time and confirmed the resident was DNR, and the DON confirmed the resident's orders and POLST indicated DNR.
Missing Current CPR Certification for Licensed Nurses
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to maintain documentation that its nursing personnel had current education and certification to provide basic life support, including CPR, prior to the arrival of emergency medical personnel and subject to physician orders and residents’ advance directives. A review of the facility’s CPR policy showed it was intended to ensure timely and appropriate initiation of CPR by licensed nursing staff in accordance with facility policy, resident rights, and federal and state regulations. During the survey, the facility provided a list of 41 currently employed licensed nurses and copies of CPR certification cards for review. CPR certification cards were not available for RN Employees E3, E4, E5, E6, and E7 and LPN Employees E8 through E16, totaling 14 of 41 licensed nurses. In an interview, the Nursing Home Administrator and the DON confirmed that the facility failed to ensure these nursing personnel maintained current CPR certification for Healthcare Providers through a CPR provider whose training included a hands-on session in a physical or virtual instructor-led setting in accordance with accepted national standards.
Failure to Start CPR for Full Code Resident
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to assess a resident for a pulse or vital signs and failed to immediately start CPR for a resident who was a full code and was found unresponsive. Resident #60 had diagnoses including multiple fractured ribs on the left side, acute respiratory failure with hypoxia and hypercapnia, type 2 diabetes mellitus with diabetic peripheral angiopathy, CHF, PVD, osteoarthritis of the left knee, and atherosclerotic heart disease of the native coronary artery. The resident’s code status was documented as full code, and the care plan stated CPR should be started and EMS called if needed. According to the CCTV timeline and staff statements, an agency CNA found the resident unresponsive during rounds and summoned nursing staff. An agency RN arrived at the room, briefly entered, and then left without taking vital signs, checking for a pulse, or starting CPR. The RN then went to the nurses’ station and made calls while the resident remained without CPR. Other agency CNAs were present, but they were not CPR certified. EMS arrived several minutes later and found the resident unresponsive, pulseless, and apneic, with no evidence that facility staff had started CPR before EMS arrival. The 911 audio, CAD log, EMS report, police report, and witness statements all reflected that the resident was found unresponsive and that the facility did not initiate CPR. The police officer reported staff were standing in the room and did not know what to do, and EMS reported the facility staff did not start CPR and did not know the approximate down time. The hospital record stated the resident had been found unresponsive by nursing facility staff, no CPR had been performed by the facility for over ten minutes, and EMS initiated CPR and ACLS during transport. The resident was later pronounced dead at the hospital.
Failure to Maintain Current CPR Certification for Nursing Staff
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to ensure that a nurse and a CNA maintained current CPR certification while working in the facility. Surveyor interviews and record review showed that facility leadership and HR stated that RNs, LPNs, and CNAs were required to have active CPR certification, and that CPR was needed because staff would respond during a code until EMS arrived. Despite this, the surveyor was unable to obtain a current CPR certification card for a CNA after multiple requests to the Administrator, Assistant Administrator, and DON, and the HR Director stated that the CNA had not produced a valid CPR certification for the employee file. Record review also showed that an LPN had worked multiple night shifts while her CPR certification had expired. The LPN confirmed receiving an HR email about the expiration and stated she renewed her CPR certification on the day of the interview. The expired CPR certificate showed the prior certification had lapsed before the renewal date. The HR Director stated she had sent an email about the upcoming expiration but did not follow up after returning from medical leave. Daily staffing schedules showed that the LPN and CNA worked multiple shifts during the review period despite not having active CPR certification. The facility’s job descriptions for both LPNs and CNAs stated that current CPR certification was required. The facility census report showed 149 residents in the facility at the time of the survey.
Delayed CPR Initiation for Full-Code Resident
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to initiate CPR in a timely manner for a resident who was full code and found unresponsive. The resident had diagnoses including atrial fibrillation, liver cirrhosis, and osteomyelitis of the right ankle and foot, and the MDS documented moderately impaired cognition. The medical orders, MOLST, and care plan all documented full code/CPR status. Surveillance video showed that after a family member alerted staff that the resident was unresponsive, RN #11 and PCT #5 entered the room without emergency equipment. RN #12, the Assistant DON, later entered the room without equipment, and no medical equipment was observed being brought to the room for several minutes. The video also showed multiple staff entering and exiting the room over time, with the AED, AMBU bag, cardiac board, and crash cart not brought in until much later. The Code Blue/CPR worksheet documented CPR as initiated at 7:01 PM, while other records and staff statements reflected delays and inconsistent times for when the resident was found, when CPR began, and when EMS was called. Staff interviews described that the resident was breathing slowly at first, then became unresponsive, with inability to obtain a pulse or blood pressure. PCTs stated they notified RN #11 after the family member reported trouble breathing, and one PCT stated RN #12 said the resident had already passed away before CPR began. RN #14 stated they responded to an overhead Code Blue and saw RN #12 performing CPR, while the DON later stated the facility’s investigation found CPR was not initiated until RN #13 entered the room. The resident expired at 7:22 PM, and the death certificate listed myocardial infarction as the cause of death.
LPNs and RNs Lacked Acceptable CPR Certification
Penalty
Summary
Facility nursing personnel did not maintain current CPR certification for Healthcare Providers through a CPR provider whose training included a hands-on session either in a physical or virtual instructor-led setting in accordance with accepted national standards for 16 of 33 licensed nurses. The affected staff included LPNs E1 through E12 and RNs E13 through E16. The facility policy titled Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation CPR stated that licensed nurses, respiratory therapists, and van drivers must hold active CPR certification for healthcare providers, and that online-only courses were not acceptable. Review of the CPR certification cards for the 16 licensed nurses showed that their certification was from an online-only CPR class for non-healthcare providers and did not include a hands-on session. During an interview, the Human Resources Director confirmed that these employees did not have the appropriate CPR certification for licensed nurses. The Nursing Home Administrator and the DON also confirmed that the facility failed to ensure that facility nursing personnel maintained current CPR certification for Healthcare Providers through a CPR provider whose training included a hands-on session either in a physical or virtual instructor-led setting.
CPR Performed Despite Active DNR Order
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to confirm the code status of Resident 96 during an emergency when LN 3 performed CPR after the resident was found unresponsive. Resident 96 had been readmitted with a diagnosis of congestive heart failure, and the record showed an active physician order for DNR, along with an MDS assessment and POLST indicating DNR and allowing natural death to occur. During interview, LN 3 stated CPR was performed after Resident 96 was found unresponsive and that she reviewed the physician order at that time and confirmed the resident's code status was DNR. The MDS Coordinator confirmed the POLST and MDS assessment indicated DNR, and the DON confirmed the OSR showed an active DNR order and stated the physician's order and POLST were expected to be carried out correctly; otherwise, the resident's wishes were not honored.
Trusted data from CMS and state health departments
Every citation, penalty and Plan of Correction is sourced from public CMS records (latest release October 8, 2026) and official state health department websites — never guesswork.
In your survey window? See what surveyors are citing.
The Survey-Prep Report maps your facility's risk from 12 months of CMS and state citation data — what's being cited around you and what to check first. $129 one-time.