F0848 F848: Provide a neutral and fair arbitration process and agree to arbitrator and venue.
F

Arbitration Agreement Lacks Mutual Selection of Neutral Arbitrator

Aventura At The BaySaint Petersburg, Florida Survey Completed on 08-28-2025

Summary

The facility failed to ensure that its arbitration agreement allowed for the selection of a neutral arbitrator mutually agreed upon by both parties, as required. Record review showed that the agreement specified arbitration would be conducted by the American Health Lawyers Association (AHLA) through its Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) service, and if unavailable, the facility would unilaterally select another ADR entity. This process did not provide residents with a choice in the selection of the arbitrator. The agreement was signed by three residents. During interviews, the Admission Coordinator acknowledged that the agreement did not appear to give residents a choice in arbitration, and the Nursing Home Administrator (NHA) indicated unfamiliarity with the agreement and was unable to provide a relevant policy or procedure.

Penalty

Inspection fine: $172,120
tooltip icon
The penalty, as released by CMS, applies to the entire inspection this citation is part of, covering all citations and f-tags issued, not just this specific f-tag. For the complete original report, please refer to the 'Details' section.

Resources

Below are regulatory guidelines relevant to this citation:

See other F0848 citations
Arbitration Agreement Missing Convenient Venue Requirement
E
F0848 F848: Provide a neutral and fair arbitration process and agree to arbitrator and venue.
Short Summary

Arbitration Agreement Missing Convenient Venue Requirement: The facility's arbitration agreement did not include a venue selection that was convenient to both parties, as required by CMS SOM Appendix PP and the federal regulation reviewed by surveyors. The deficiency applied to all residents who had signed an arbitration agreement, and the Administrator acknowledged that the agreement was missing this regulatory requirement.

No penalty information released
tooltip icon
The penalty, as released by CMS, applies to the entire inspection this citation is part of, covering all citations and f-tags issued, not just this specific f-tag. For the complete original report, please refer to the 'Details' section.
Arbitration Agreement Lacked Neutral Arbitrator and Venue Provisions
D
F0848 F848: Provide a neutral and fair arbitration process and agree to arbitrator and venue.
Short Summary

The facility failed to ensure a neutral and fair arbitration process because its arbitration agreement did not show that both the resident and/or resident representative and the facility agreed on the arbitrator or the venue. Review of the agreement found no evidence that the venue would be convenient to both parties, and the NHA confirmed the language did not provide for mutual selection of a neutral arbitrator or venue.

No penalty information released
tooltip icon
The penalty, as released by CMS, applies to the entire inspection this citation is part of, covering all citations and f-tags issued, not just this specific f-tag. For the complete original report, please refer to the 'Details' section.
Binding Arbitration Agreement Lacked Neutral Arbitrator and Convenient Venue Provisions
F
F0848 F848: Provide a neutral and fair arbitration process and agree to arbitrator and venue.
Short Summary

A review of signed arbitration agreements for three residents found no documented evidence that the agreements allowed selection of a neutral arbitrator agreed upon by both parties or a venue convenient to both parties. The agreements stated arbitration would take place in Vvv County, NY, and staff interviews showed the DON and admissions leadership were unaware of the required language and believed the documents related to Medicaid/Medicare coverage rather than arbitration terms.

No penalty information released
tooltip icon
The penalty, as released by CMS, applies to the entire inspection this citation is part of, covering all citations and f-tags issued, not just this specific f-tag. For the complete original report, please refer to the 'Details' section.
Arbitration Agreement Lacked Neutral Arbitrator Choice and Convenient Venue
E
F0848 F848: Provide a neutral and fair arbitration process and agree to arbitrator and venue.
Short Summary

Arbitration agreement language required use of a named lawyers association and allowed the facility to select an alternate arbitration service if that group could not serve, while venue was also selected by the facility. Three residents who signed the agreement said they did not remember it being explained, did not know what arbitration was, or did not know if they had signed a contract. The ADON/Admissions staff and Administrator stated they were unsure what would happen if a resident declined the listed arbitrator or found the venue inconvenient.

No penalty information released
tooltip icon
The penalty, as released by CMS, applies to the entire inspection this citation is part of, covering all citations and f-tags issued, not just this specific f-tag. For the complete original report, please refer to the 'Details' section.
Arbitration Agreements Pre-Determined the Arbitrator
E
F0848 F848: Provide a neutral and fair arbitration process and agree to arbitrator and venue.
Short Summary

Arbitration agreements for two residents pre-selected JAMS, or if unavailable NAF, as the arbitration service, rather than providing a neutral and fair process with an agreed-upon arbitrator and venue. The SSD signed the facility representative section of both agreements and stated they had not received training on arbitration agreements and were unaware of the regulations governing them.

Inspection fine: $32,576
tooltip icon
The penalty, as released by CMS, applies to the entire inspection this citation is part of, covering all citations and f-tags issued, not just this specific f-tag. For the complete original report, please refer to the 'Details' section.
Arbitration Agreements Lacked Venue Selection Language
E
F0848 F848: Provide a neutral and fair arbitration process and agree to arbitrator and venue.
Short Summary

Arbitration Agreements Lacked Venue Selection Language: The facility failed to ensure arbitration agreements for three residents included a venue selection convenient to both parties. Record review showed the residents had significant medical conditions, and the DCM confirmed the agreements did not contain the required venue information. The ADMIN stated the form did not provide for venue selection and the facility had no P&P for arbitration agreements.

No penalty information released
tooltip icon
The penalty, as released by CMS, applies to the entire inspection this citation is part of, covering all citations and f-tags issued, not just this specific f-tag. For the complete original report, please refer to the 'Details' section.
Citation search

Search every citation & Plan of Correction

Go to search
Citation watch

Track new serious citations across Florida

Get a heads-up on the newest immediate-jeopardy (J–L) citations in Florida — where surveyors are focused right now.

Free · about one email a month

Trusted data from CMS and state health departments

Every citation, penalty and Plan of Correction is sourced from public CMS records (latest release October 8, 2026) and official state health department websites — never guesswork.

In your survey window? See what surveyors are citing.

The Survey-Prep Report maps your facility's risk from 12 months of CMS and state citation data — what's being cited around you and what to check first. $129 one-time.

Get the Survey-Prep Report
An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙

Connection lost — reconnecting… We couldn't reconnect automatically. Please reload the page to continue.