F0689

J

Elopements of High-Risk Residents and Firearm Discharge Due to Inadequate Supervision and Safety Controls

Columbus, Ohio Survey Completed on 01-29-2026

Penalty

No penalty information released

Summary

The deficiency involves the facility’s failure to ensure adequate supervision and a hazard‑free environment, resulting in multiple elopements and the presence and discharge of a firearm inside the building. One cognitively impaired resident with vascular dementia, severe cognitive impairment, and a documented high risk for elopement was ordered to reside on a secured memory care unit. His care plan and secured unit screener specified that he was an elopement risk, wandered or would wander out of the facility, required a secure unit per physician order, and needed a structured environment with specialized activities. Despite these assessments and orders, a CNA took him off the secured unit to smoke with other memory care residents, then left him unattended at the elevator in the first‑floor lobby, pressing the elevator button and walking away. Video review later showed the resident leaving through the front door a few minutes later, while the front desk receptionist was at lunch, and staff did not realize he was missing from the secured unit until over an hour later.

The same resident’s elopement was reconstructed through staff witness statements, facility investigation, and external records. Staff statements indicated that the resident was last seen on the secured unit around breakfast and morning rounds, then taken out to smoke around late morning. After the smoke break, the CNA who escorted him did not remain with him, and he was left in an unsecured area. Nursing staff and activities staff later searched the unit and building after he was reported missing, and the DON notified police and the resident’s responsible parties. A police report and hospital records documented that bystanders found the resident on a sidewalk approximately 1.2 miles from the facility, in hot weather conditions, after he had walked away from the building and crossed a high‑traffic multi‑lane street. Hospital documentation showed he was brought to the ED by EMS after a witnessed fall and was treated for a non‑ST elevation myocardial infarction, acute kidney injury, and slight dehydration.

A second cognitively impaired resident with aphasia following a stroke, communication deficits, impaired insight and memory, and documented lack of medical decision‑making capacity was assessed by the facility as high risk for elopement shortly after admission. The interim care plan noted cognitive and visual impairment and that the resident would not be able to easily communicate with staff, and physician orders directed staff to monitor behaviors including wandering. However, the resident did not have a care plan addressing her identified high elopement risk. She left the facility unattended in the early morning hours, as later confirmed by facility video reviewed by police, and was seen by another resident packing her bags and crossing streets near the parking lot. Nursing notes showed that staff initially searched the building and grounds without finding her, notified the physician and on‑call nurse, and contacted family members hours after she had left. Family interviews and the police missing persons detective confirmed there was a delay of more than seven hours between the time she exited the building and when law enforcement was notified, during which time she remained away from the facility until returning later that day.

The facility also failed to maintain a safe environment when an RN brought a firearm into the building and it discharged in a common area near resident rooms on the second floor. According to the regional director of operations and the police preliminary investigation report, the RN stated he had a firearm in his coat pocket, forgot it was there when he came to work, and hung the coat in the locked medication room. During a break, he put the coat on, placed his hand in the pocket, and the firearm discharged, creating a bullet hole in the floor and a ricochet into the wall of a resident room. Staff and residents on the unit heard a loud bang and saw dust and damage to the floor and wall, and one CNA reported finding bullet casings on the floor. The RN did not immediately inform other staff about the firearm or the cause of the loud noise and smoke, and management only learned of the incident later during their investigation. This occurred despite a written facility policy prohibiting employees, residents, visitors, vendors, or others from possessing firearms or other weapons on the premises.

In addition, review of the facility’s elopement policy revealed it required staff to investigate and report all cases of missing residents but did not contain safety measures or protocols to identify residents at risk for potential elopement. This lack of detailed procedural guidance existed alongside the documented cases in which one resident at high risk for elopement on a secured unit was taken off that unit and left unsupervised in an unsecured area, and another high‑risk resident with significant communication and cognitive deficits had no elopement care plan and was able to leave the building unaccompanied during the night. These combined findings formed the basis of the cited deficiency for failure to keep the environment free from accident hazards and to provide adequate supervision to prevent accidents.

Removal Plan

• Completed a Root Cause Analysis by the Administrator with input from the management team.
• Created a list of residents on the secured unit who are smokers and distributed it to staff.
• Completed whole house elopement risk assessments and updated care plans accordingly by the DON and Unit Manager LPN #262.
• Held an ad-hoc QAPI meeting to discuss elopement policy best practices and supervision of secured unit residents while off the secured unit.
• Updated the bed board to include leave of absence status after review of current resident room locations and new elopement risk assessment.
• Educated all staff on the elopement policy best practices and supervision of residents off the secured unit.
• Updated staff smoking assignments.
• Updated the facility's elopement binders to include resident's name and picture, current smokers list, elopement policy and missing resident best practices.
• Conduct audits three times a week for four weeks to ensure any resident taken off the secured unit is supervised at all times while off the unit.
• Conduct elopement drills once a week on day shift and once a week on night shift for four weeks.