Failure to Honor Resident's Right to Dignity and Self-Determination
Summary
A deficiency occurred when a Certified Nurse Assistant (CNA) entered the room of a resident who had previously requested not to receive care from that CNA, following a complaint from the resident's family member. Despite an agreement that the CNA would not be assigned to provide care to this resident, the CNA entered the resident's room to provide care to the roommate and closed the curtain for privacy. Staffing records confirmed that the CNA was assigned to the roommate, not the resident in question, but the Director of Nursing (DON) acknowledged that, due to the known conflict and complaints, the CNA should not have been assigned to the room at all. The resident involved had multiple medical conditions, including hemiplegia, hemiparesis, acute respiratory failure, diabetes mellitus, asthma, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The resident's cognitive skills were moderately impaired, and they were dependent on staff for all activities of daily living. The facility's policy stated that residents have the right to be treated with respect, kindness, and dignity, and to participate in decision-making regarding their care. The failure to honor the resident's request and the facility's own policy resulted in a violation of the resident's rights.
Plan Of Correction
F550 Resident Rights/Exercise of Rights 1. How corrective actions will be accomplished for those residents found to have been affected by the deficient practice. • Resident 1 remains in the facility and has no complaints/issues about his CNA. • CNA 1 will no longer be assigned to resident '1's roommate and cannot enter room since 08/02/2025. • Resident 1's care plans were reviewed and updated according to his needs. • The DON provided in-service education regarding Resident Rights Policy and Procedures to nursing, rehab, activity, respiratory, and department heads' staff on 08/14/2025, 08/15/2025, 08/18/2025, 08/19/2025, and 08/20/2025. 2. How the facility will identify other residents having the potential to be affected by the same deficient practice and what corrective actions will be taken. • The Administrator, DON, and Social Services Director (SSD) randomly interviewed alert and oriented residents to address any concerns/issues regarding their CNA, ensuring they are treated with respect, kindness, and dignity, and participate in decision-making regarding their care; no concerns/issues were brought up. • There were no other residents affected by this deficient practice. • The DON provided in-service education regarding Resident Rights Policy and Procedures to nursing, rehab, activity, respiratory, and department heads' staff on 08/14/2025, 08/15/2025, 08/18/2025, 08/19/2025, and 08/20/2025. 3. What measures will be put into place or what systemic changes will the facility make to ensure that the deficient practice does not occur. Systemic changes will be achieved through in-service education and corrective action monitoring utilizing the facility quality assurance process. • The DON provided in-service education regarding Resident Rights Policy and Procedures to nursing, rehab, activity, respiratory, and department heads' staff on 08/14/2025, 08/15/2025, 08/18/2025, 08/19/2025, and 08/20/2025. • The RN supervisor and charge nurse will review the assignment sheet every shift to ensure that staff who have issues with the resident will not be assigned to the resident's room and cannot enter the room. Any findings will be corrected immediately and reported to the DSD and DON for follow-up and corrections for future pre-assigned assignment sheets. • The RN supervisor will randomly observe staff daily when providing care to the residents to ensure residents are treated with respect, kindness, and dignity, and that staff comply with resident care plans. Any findings will be corrected immediately and reported to the DON for follow-up and corrective actions. • Department Heads will conduct daily room rounds and interview the residents regarding any concerns/issues regarding their CNA, ensuring they are treated with respect, kindness, and dignity, and participate in decision-making regarding their care. Immediate correction will be carried out upon notice of issues/concerns. Any findings during their room rounds will be discussed in the stand-up meeting for corrective actions and follow-up. • The DSD or designee will continue to provide in-service education regarding Resident Rights. 4. How the facility plans to monitor its performance to make sure that solutions are sustained. The Administrator and/or DON shall implement, monitor, and evaluate this Plan of Correction. The SSD or designee will recapitulate findings related to Resident Rights issues at the monthly QAA meeting for further evaluation, recommendation, and/or appropriate improvement actions. If it is determined that we have accomplished the objectives in the Plan of Corrections above and the results are successful, then the facility will consider the matter resolved. The QAA Committee will continue to review until the deficiency has been proven resolved for two consecutive months and/or advised by the QAA Committee.
Penalty
Resources
Below are regulatory guidelines relevant to this citation:
Failure to maintain resident dignity was identified when three residents with indwelling urinary catheters had drainage bags hanging on the bedframe without privacy covers, despite physician orders for privacy covers every shift. In addition, a resident who was ordered to be fed by staff was observed being fed by a nurse aide standing beside the bed during lunch, and the DON confirmed the dining experience was not dignified.
A resident with dementia, anxiety, and osteoarthritis was observed sitting naked on the bed in full view of the hallway while a CNA assisted with dressing. The care plan directed staff to assist with dressing, and the CNA stated the curtain had not been pulled after returning the resident from the bathroom. The ED confirmed the facility failed to maintain the resident's dignity.
Failure to provide a dignified dining experience: Four residents with significant diagnoses, including Parkinson’s disease, schizophrenia, cerebral palsy, TBI, and dysphagia, were brought to the assistive dining room for lunch but were not served their trays until more than 50 minutes after the posted mealtime. While other residents were already being assisted with eating, these residents were left watching the meal service, and the DON stated they should have been served at the same time as the others or not brought in until their trays were ready.
A facility failed to protect the dignity of two residents when an LPN administered insulin injections in the commons area in full view of surveyors, staff, and other residents. The LPN lifted each resident’s shirt, cleansed the injection site, and gave the subcutaneous insulin injection publicly rather than in a private area.
A resident with dementia, depression, and anxiety was seated in the dining room while other residents ate, but the lunch tray was not served with the group on two occasions. In a separate event, an LVN administered oral meds to another resident with intellectual disability and cerebral palsy in the dining room while wearing gloves, rather than in a private setting, which staff stated was not the facility’s practice and could be seen as disrespectful.
A resident with dementia and Alzheimer's disease had his beard completely shaved by two CNAs without his RP's consent. The RP stated the resident had worn his beard for many years and had not been seen without it, and the DON stated the RP should have been notified because the resident lacked capacity to make decisions for himself. The facility policy required staff to ask the resident or, when appropriate, the resident representative about grooming preferences upon admission.
Failure to Maintain Resident Dignity During Catheter Care and Dining
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to maintain resident dignity by not ensuring privacy covers were applied to urinary catheter drainage bags for three residents. Resident R26, who had diagnoses of diabetes, high blood pressure, and coronary artery disease, had a physician order for catheter care to provide a privacy cover for the drainage bag every shift. During observation, the catheter drainage bag was hanging on the bedframe without a privacy cover. Resident R178, with diagnoses of diabetes, high blood pressure, and depression, also had an order for a privacy cover every shift, and the drainage bag was observed hanging on the bedframe without a privacy cover. Resident R179, diagnosed with COPD, atrial fibrillation, and heart failure, likewise had an order for a privacy cover every shift, and the drainage bag was observed hanging on the bedframe without a privacy cover. An RN confirmed that the bags should be covered and that the residents' dignity was not maintained. The facility also failed to provide a dignified dining experience for one resident who was ordered to be fed by staff. Resident R39, who had diagnoses of high blood pressure, heart failure, and diabetes, had a care plan and physician order for staff to feed all meals. During lunch observation on the 2B nursing unit, the resident was sitting upright in bed while a nurse aide stood beside the bed feeding the resident. The nurse aide stated that they should have been sitting down while feeding but did not know where the resident's chair was. The DON later confirmed that the facility failed to provide the right to a dignified dining experience for one of two lunches observed on 2B.
Failure to Maintain Resident Dignity During Dressing Assistance
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to provide care and services to maintain a resident's dignity for one of 11 sampled residents. Resident R23 had diagnoses including dementia, anxiety, and osteoarthritis. The MDS dated [DATE] indicated the resident had mild cognitive impairment and required assistance with dressing. The care plan identified a self-care performance deficit related to dementia and directed staff to assist the resident with dressing. During observation on 8/4/2026 at 10:15 a.m., Resident R23 was sitting on the bed naked in full view of anyone walking by in the hallway while a CNA was assisting with dressing. During interview, the CNA stated that the curtain had not been pulled after bringing the resident back from the bathroom, and the Executive Director confirmed the findings and that the facility failed to provide care and services to maintain the resident's dignity.
Failure to Provide Dignified Dining Experience
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to ensure residents were treated with dignity and respect for 4 of 8 residents reviewed for respect and dignity. The facility’s Assistance with Meals policy stated that staff will serve resident trays and help residents who require assistance with eating, and that residents who cannot feed themselves will be fed with attention to safety, comfort, and dignity. The facility’s Dignity policy stated that each resident shall be cared for in a manner that promotes and enhances well-being, satisfaction with life, and feelings of self-worth and self-esteem, and that residents are supported in exercising their rights during care. Resident #4 had diagnoses including Parkinson’s Disease and major depressive disorder. Resident #13 had diagnoses including schizophrenia and abnormal involuntary movement. Resident #19 had diagnoses including spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy and anxiety disorder. Resident #44 had diagnoses including traumatic brain injury and dysphagia. During observation of the assistive dining room during the lunch meal, eight residents were present and only four were being assisted with eating after their meals had been delivered. Residents #4, #13, #19, and #44 were not served their lunch trays until after 12:10 PM, more than 50 minutes past the posted lunch mealtime, and were observed watching other residents who were already being assisted with their meals. The DON stated these residents should have been served at the same time as the other residents or not brought into the dining room until their trays were ready.
Failure to Protect Resident Dignity During Insulin Administration
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to provide care for R4 and R1 in a manner that protected and promoted their dignity. On 08/04/2026 at 07:32 AM, observation in the commons area showed LN G pulling up R4's shirt on his left arm, cleansing the area with an alcohol wipe, and administering a subcutaneous insulin injection in his right upper arm while two surveyors, multiple facility employees, and numerous other residents could view the procedure from the four halls and dining room area. On 08/04/2026 at 07:40 AM, a similar observation in the commons area showed LN G pulling up R1's shirt on his left arm, cleansing with an alcohol wipe, and administering a subcutaneous insulin injection in his right upper arm in full view of two surveyors, multiple facility employees, and numerous other residents. On 08/05/2026 at 08:10 AM, Administrative Nurse D verified that LN G should not administer insulin injections in public areas and that residents should be taken to their rooms or a private area. The facility's Respect and Dignity; Right to Personal Property policy, dated August 2026, stated residents have the right to be treated with respect and dignity.
Late Meal Service and Public Medication Administration
Penalty
Summary
Facility staff failed to promote dignity and respect for Resident 3 when the resident’s lunch tray was not served with the other residents in the dining room on 7/30/2026 and again on 7/31/2026. Resident 3 was admitted with diagnoses including dementia, major depressive disorder, and anxiety, and the MDS indicated the resident had moderately impaired cognitive skills for daily decision making and required supervision or substantial assistance with multiple activities of daily living. During observation, Resident 3 was seated at a dining table with other residents while the other residents were eating, but Resident 3 had no lunch tray present. During the first observation, Treatment Nurse 1 verified that Resident 3 had no lunch tray and was watching the other residents eat, and stated he did not know why the tray was not included with the others. The Assistant DON later stated the resident was not served lunch on time and should have been served between 12:00 PM and 12:15 PM with the other residents in the dining room. On the second day, Resident 3 was again observed seated at the dining table at 12:15 PM with no lunch tray while other residents were eating. The DON and Dietary Supervisor stated the delay left the resident waiting while others ate, and the Dietary Supervisor stated the system for getting the dining room resident list to the kitchen staff was not working. Facility staff also failed to maintain Resident 4’s dignity during medication administration in the dining room. Resident 4 was admitted with diagnoses including mood disorder, intellectual disability, and cerebral palsy, and the MDS indicated the resident required substantial assistance with several activities of daily living. During observation, LVN 1 administered oral medication to Resident 4 in the dining room while wearing gloves. Treatment Nurse 1 stated medication should not be given in a public area and that the resident should have been assisted back to the room for private medication administration. The DON stated the resident could feel disrespected and that other residents might think the resident had an infectious disease because staff wore gloves while giving the medication.
Unauthorized Shaving of Resident's Beard
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to ensure that two CNAs did not shave the beard of one resident without the resident's RP's consent. The resident had diagnoses including dementia and Alzheimer's disease, and his MDS indicated his cognition was moderately impaired and that he was dependent on facility staff for ADLs. The resident's RP stated that the beard was shaved without her knowledge or consent and that the resident had worn his beard for many years and she had never seen him without it. The DON stated that the RP should have been notified before the resident's beard was shaved because the resident did not have capacity to make decisions for himself. The DON also stated that CNA 1 and CNA 2 reported the resident looked unkempt and dirty on admission and that they felt he needed grooming. The facility policy on resident preferences stated staff should ask the resident and, when appropriate, the resident representative about preferences upon admission before initiation of treatment/therapy and/or during the initial IDT meeting, including preferences related to grooming.
Trusted data from CMS and state health departments
Every citation, penalty and Plan of Correction is sourced from public CMS records (latest release October 8, 2026) and official state health department websites — never guesswork.
In your survey window? See what surveyors are citing.
The Survey-Prep Report maps your facility's risk from 12 months of CMS and state citation data — what's being cited around you and what to check first. $129 one-time.